Current Long-Term Care Facility Survey System Carries the Risk of Producing Sterilized Care

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) conducts surveys of long-term care facilities following the protocols set up to determine whether a facility is following regulations and eligible for recertification. But are these surveys producing 'sterilized care?"

Recommend This Page
Current Long-Term Care Facility Survey System Carries the Risk of Producing Sterilized Care
9 Min Read January 13th, 2022

The current survey process in long-term care is flawed due to a punitive approach that prioritizes documenting care over the care itself. Surveyors are tasked with searching for violations, which means they are not allowed the opportunity to consider regional or cultural differences and nursing priorities. Nurses, in turn, become focused on not getting caught for violations, which prevents them from building real relationships with residents and learning how to best cater to their care needs. And regulations are often avoided until close to the survey date, rendering them a mere formality. All of these issues result in a form of sterilized care

Make no mistake about it: the problem has been known for decades. It was just never resolved. Back in 1982, the Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA) proposed changes to regulations, in response to long-term care providers complaining about the unreasonableness of some regulations. The proposed changes would have helped ease annual inspections in nursing homes. However, the proposition was strongly opposed by states and consumer groups who doubted that it would actually improve the quality of care in nursing homes. With nursing homes facing more challenges than ever, we can no longer sit back and accept the limitations of the current survey system. 

Surveys Are Not Focused on Quality of Life

Currently, surveys are a penalty-based compliance system that simply ensures facilities observe federal regulations. Unfortunately, the regulations are so burdensome that they discourage nurses and other team members from pursuing the actual goals of the facility: improving quality of life and maintaining dignity. As a result, there is a growing sentiment that they have simply become unreasonable. 

At the same time, the regulations in place are not encompassing enough. While PDPM has shifted focus to the complexity of care (as opposed to simply counting therapy minutes, for instance), the system still demands that surveyors focus on checking boxes, leaving them little opportunity to actually assess the nature of care at each specific facility. 

Technical regulations have resulted in surveyors becoming hyper-focused on details that don’t always affect a resident’s overall health and quality of life. Yes, terms like patient rights and dignity are used, but there is too much room for interpretation. We need to better define patient rights, which, as it stands, functions as nothing but an umbrella term for care in general. And we need to consider regional context and other circumstantial factors in our understanding of dignity. 

Consider these examples of violations that can be nitpicky, culturally, or regionally insensitive, or simply tone-deaf: 

  • A visible privacy bag - A privacy bag can be as simple as a vinyl flap that covers the urine in the bag. The flap isn’t that durable, which means it can fold during use. If the bag of urine is visible, a surveyor is technically supposed to report a violation of the resident’s rights, even if the resident is not bothered by the incident at all.
  • Endearing words - A nurse may come from a region where calling a senior “honey” or “sweetheart” is entirely acceptable. A surveyor with no awareness of this cultural or regional difference decides to issue a citation even though the resident is not bothered at all simply because it was not documented in the resident’s care plan.
  • Calling a resident by their first name - A surveyor with no understanding of the dynamic between resident and employee can report the latter for not addressing the former using an honorific (“Mr.,” “Mrs.,” etc.). This is despite the fact that the resident might have actually requested to be called by their first name.
  • Strong tones of voice - Different situations call for different tones. For example, in facilities with many veterans, the overall environment and tone of speech would be different compared to a facility where most residents were stay-at-home wives. The veterans’ environment may be more formal, with a direct and firm tone of voice being used by nurses. For a surveyor who is on the outside looking in, it might seem insensitive, but it could be that the former veterans prefer to be addressed that way on account of the value they place in being direct and disciplined.

Context, Communication, and Collaboration

Skilled nursing facilities should not be punished when regulations are not observed but the standard of care and outcomes remain unaffected. For instance, a resident may miss a lab test but suffer no harm as a result. The tendency is to issue a tag immediately, whereas a wiser approach would be for the surveyor to make a recommendation and thus encourage the facility to act responsibly as opposed to out of fear. 

There needs to be a collegial relationship between surveyors and facilities. In fact, that is the way it used to be. Prior to today’s (very extensive) regulations, surveyors would come in and talk with long-term care staff. If the surveyor saw something they didn’t like, they would ask for an explanation. Only if the explanation was insufficient would the facility get a tag. But surveyors are so overwhelmed with following protocols that they no longer have the time for such conversations with nurses and CNAs. Instead, they are asked to play the roles of both judge and jury for nursing homes. Surveyors need to be allowed to have open and honest conversations with nurses and the freedom to evaluate residents as people, as we are a complicated species that cannot be easily compartmentalized. 

Above, I mentioned examples in which a lack of contextual understanding could impel surveyors to cite a facility for something that didn’t even violate residents’ rights. But sometimes, it’s not even about context but rather basic empathy. As we face a devastating current staffing shortage, surveyors must be allowed to consider that nursing homes sometimes have to make tough decisions. A team may have to choose between giving residents their showers and documenting care. If they prioritize the hygiene and health of residents, though, they will receive tags. 

Another reason harmless incidents are identified as infractions is that some surveyors lack sufficient clinical training and are, rather, more experienced as social workers. Others may have clinical training but are far removed from their nursing days. So, when surveyors step inside a building, they may begin interpreting regulations based on their limited (or lost) understanding of the reality of how care is delivered. That means they miss certain things and misinterpret others, which forces nurses to contest their claims, taking time and care away from residents. This further makes evident the need for a dialogue between staff and surveyors. 

Problems with the Current Survey Method

Surveys are supposed to operate as pop quizzes that ensure facilities are on top of their game at all times. However, the reality is that it becomes apparent that surveyors are coming weeks in advance. And nearby facilities can give a heads-up as close as three to four days before a survey. That allows teams to conduct mock surveys to prepare and even delay observing the stricter (more irrational) regulations until close to the survey date. 

In many cases, a facility will know surveyors are coming in the next 30 minutes and will have the time to quickly write dates on oxygen tubes or fulfill other obligations that they normally would ignore. The receptionist may even use a fictitious name as a code word and page that name to alert the staff that the state surveyor is in the building, allowing the staff to address any last-minute issues.

In other words, the granularity expected of nursing homes is not sustainable and is only observed to appease surveyors. These details, thus, serve very little purpose. Facilities that know their turn for a survey is far in advance will go about their business as they see best, acting within the limitations of a shorthanded staff to provide what they think is the kind of care their residents require. They will then show something quite different when surveyors—especially those who are not clinically trained and thus will not be suspicious—arrive.

Another issue with surveys is that the interview process is not thorough enough. Oftentimes, only five or six residents will be interviewed. Sometimes this is due to the limited number of residents with the appropriate BIMS scores, especially at smaller facilities. But another factor is the nature of these interviews. Surveyors may come across three residents that have nothing about which to comment and then simply be forced to move on to other areas due to the demanding nature of the current survey system. And because surveyors are tasked with adhering to predetermined questions and protocols, they are not able to give interviewees the opportunity to seriously contemplate and then articulate their concerns. Lastly, in complaint surveys (as opposed to broader, annual surveys), surveyors may have to limit the focus to a particular complaint wording, which prevents opening things up to other potential issues during interviews. 

Conclusion

Long-term care annual surveys operate as checklists, whereas they need to work more as evaluations that lead to a collaborative effort to improve care in accordance with the context at hand. An emphasis on detailed documentation—as opposed to things like how long residents need to wait before receiving care—wastes resources and distracts from more fundamental issues at facilities. 

Part of the problem is that surveyors are not always afforded sufficient training on the ins and outs of long-term care, or they may be far removed from their own clinical experiences in long-term care. And it is natural that those tasked with emphasizing regulations will occasionally fail to approach matters from a clinical perspective, especially as there is a great deal of room for interpretation. That is why we need more dialog and communication between surveyors and nurses in our facilities so that the two parties can learn to dig deeper and unearth the concerns and discomforts of our seniors.

Recommend This Page

About the Author

Charles Oliver has over thirty years of experience in long-term care as an LPN, wound nurse, unit manager, MDS, ADON, DON, regional consultant, EHR implementation specialist, regional QA five-star case-mix consultant, and informatics nurse. Oliver now shares his expertise about survey management, staffing strategies, clinical project creation, systems training and analysis, and EHR implementation with leaders across the United States in his capacity as the director of customer success at Experience Care, a long-term care software provider.

LTC News Contributor Charles Oliver

Charles Oliver

Contributor since January 13th, 2022

Editor's Note

If you have a loved one who needs to be in a long-term care facility, you want them to have the best quality care. The same would apply to in-home care providers.

When you need care in the decades ahead, you will want for yourself quality care in the setting you desire. Owning a Long-Term Care Insurance policy is one way to ensure you get quality care without draining assets or placing stress on your family.

People need long-term health care services for many reasons. Whether we have mobility problems, health or aging issues, or dementia, long-term health care is expensive and a burden on family members.

Quality care options are even more expensive and sometimes can be hard to find. The time to prepare for the costs and burdens of aging is when we are younger and still enjoy good health. Most people want to avoid a family crisis when they get older. Few would want to burden their adult children when better options are available. 

For anyone with savings, a Long-Term Care Insurance policy can be an affordable solution. LTC Insurance is custom designed so you and a specialist can determine the appropriate amount of benefits based on your budget and your needs.

Most Long-Term Care Insurance claims are for in-home care, and most claims start at home. In 2021 the top insurance companies paid over $12.3 Billion in Long-Term Care Insurance benefits. 

Keep in mind; however, you cannot buy a policy when you need it as these policies are medically underwritten. Don't assume you cannot qualify. Seek the help of a qualified specialist who works with the top companies to help match you with the best company. Underwriting criteria, and premiums, vary dramatically between insurance companies. 

Most people obtain Long-Term Care Insurance coverage in their 50s.

Find Quality Caregivers and Long-Term Care Facilities

If your parent or loved one needs care now - or soon - you will need to find the appropriate care in the right setting depending on their needs.

Take a moment and read - 

Seek Professional Guidance

Insurance rates are regulated, so no insurance agent, agency, or financial advisor can give you special deals. However, premiums do vary over 100% between insurance companies for the same coverage.

Experts suggest using a qualified Long-Term Care Insurance specialist to help you navigate the many options available to you and your family.

A specialist who works with the top companies can match your age, health, family history, and other factors and find you the best coverage at the best value. A specialist will save you money, and you will have peace of mind knowing they are making the appropriate recommendations - Work With a Specialist | LTC News.

Get Expert Help Filing an LTC Insurance Claim

LTC NEWS provides free assistance with no obligation to help you or a loved one complete the claims process with your Long-Term Care Insurance policy. 

You can also get support in finding quality caregivers and get recommendations for a proper care plan, whether a person has a policy or not. - Filing a Long-Term Care Insurance Claim | LTC News

Planning Tools and Resources on LTC NEWS

You can find many tools and resources on LTC NEWS to assist you in your research for a planning solution or help your family find the appropriate care for a loved one at the time of crisis. 

To help you plan for the future costs and burdens of changing health and aging, LTC NEWS has put in place several resources, including:

Find all the resources on LTC NEWS - Resources for Long-Term Care Planning | LTC News.

Share Your Knowledge - Be A Guest Contributor for LTC NEWS

LTC NEWS is open to contributors to share their stories with the world. 

You can write a story or ongoing column for LTC NEWS. You can write about many topics, including aging, caregiving, health, lifestyle, retirement planning, and long-term care, to name a few.

Be sure to write for our core target audience of adults aged 40 and older. Our audience is worldwide; however, our primary target is the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, and other English-speaking nations. 

Improve your website or blog's SEO and gain exposure and traffic at the same time by being a contributor to LTC NEWS. 

You can even promote yourself, your business, and your website or blog. However, it must have editorial content exclusive for LTC NEWS and cannot be just an advertisement. It can include links to other sites, and you can share the article link once published on your website or social media.

Email your story idea or article: newsroom@ltcnews.com - LTC News Contributors | LTC News

Benefits of Reverse Mortgages 

Today's reverse mortgages for those aged 62 and older could be an ideal resource to fund a Long-Term Care Insurance policy OR even provide money to pay for care if you, or a loved one, already needs help and assistance.  

Some people have much of their savings invested in their homes. With today's reverse mortgages, you can find ways to fund care solutions, care itself, even help with cash flow during your retirement. 

Learn more by asking questions to an expert. LTC NEWS columnist and host of the TV Show "62 Who Knew" will answer your questions regarding caregiving, aging, health, retirement planning, long-term care, and reverse mortgages. 

Shared Links

LTC NEWS offers a 'helpful links' page so readers looking for additional information can find them easily. You can get a dofollow link to your website on LTC NEWS in exchange for a dofollow link on your site.

Let's work together and help consumers who search for us on the web - Site Request | LTC News.

You can also affordably purchase a dofollow link to your website or blog on LTC NEWS. Just contact the advertising department.

Sharing News with LTC NEWS 

Include LTC NEWS in your press release distribution. If your group, organization, business, political committee, etc., have news to share, send it to LTC NEWS. Email - newsroom@ltcnews.com   

LTC News Trusted & Verified

Get Accurate Quotes

Work With A Trusted Specialist

  • Has substantial experience in Long-Term Care Insurance
  • Strong understanding of underwriting, policy design, and claims experience
  • Represents all or most of all the leading insurance companies
man and woman sitting at desk
Connect With a Long-Term Care Specialist

Find Affordable Insurance and the Right Coverage.

LTC News Trusted & Verified
Learn More
Latest
  • Latest

  • Oldest

Everything
  • Homecare

  • Health

  • Government

  • Care Facilities

  • Pets

  • People

  • Lifestyle

  • Insurance

Step 1 of 4

Find a Specialist

Get Started Today

Trusted & Verified Specialists

Work with a trusted Long-Term Care Insurance Specialist Today

  • Has substantial experience in Long-Term Care Insurance
  • A strong understanding of underwriting, policy design, and claims experience
  • Represents all or most of all the leading insurance companies

LTC News Trusted & Verified

Compare Insurers

+

Claim this listing

Fill out this short form

Step Number:

1
2
3

Request Listing Edit

Tell us a little bit about yourself.

Step Number:

1
2
3

Are you a customer of this business, or are you an employee?